Home Galleries Staff Archives Contact Us

'The Incredibles' divides critics over slow plot and awesome action


Plot is lacking and inappropriate for kids

Nicole Donner

The Advocate

Pixar’s latest attempt at a smash fit falls short for some audience members.
“The Incredibles” begins with mega superhero, Mr. Incredible, who’s at the height of his career. That is, until he’s hit with lawsuits from rescues that went amiss. Years later, Bob “Incredible” Parr sits at a boring insurance job married to also-retired superhero, Helen “Elastigirl” Parr and their two kids, Violet and Dash. This not-so-normal suburban family tries to fit into society, while Bob wishes he could return to his crime-fighting duties.
Bob’s wish is granted when he receives a message from a top-secret yet very suspicious company. He’s flown to an island to fight a creature that almost seems unstoppable. Meanwhile, unknown to him, he’s bringing himself and his family into a secret evil plot to rid the world of all superheroes.
When I first saw the trailer in June 2003, I was on the floor laughing when an overweight Mr. Incredible was trying to buckle his belt. From then, I counted down the days until I could see this seemingly hilarious movie on the big screen. As I saw more and more commercials, nothing lived up to the belt fiasco but it remained funny. I was suspecting this movie to out-do “Finding Nemo,” which, in my opinion, is one of the funniest animated movies out there. I sat down in the packed theatre, expecting to be laughing hysterically within the first 10 minutes of the movie. Not so.
I walked out of the theater disappointed. Yes, there were funny parts (nothing like the belt situation, but still funny) but nothing had me rolling around on the ground with tears in my eyes. For the first hour and a half, the movie told the entire back-story from Mr. Incredible meeting Elastigirl to his boring job at the insurance company. There were a few giggles here and there, but nothing gut wrenching. The only breakout character I can see, or at least a quotable character, would be super suite designer to the stars, Edna Mode. With her eccentric movements and even more lovable yet loud personality, Edna stands out amongst the superheroes. Almost like a new version of other Pixar characters, Nigel from “Finding Nemo” or Roz from “Monsters Inc.” A loved, yet under-appreciated, character.
What killed me was the lack of character development. I hardly knew any of the other characters besides Bob. Violet was your typical shy teenager, Dash was the generic annoying younger brother, and Helen was the nagging voice in the back of your head. We saw Bob’s struggles but what about the rest of your family. I think Pixar needs to concentrate more on the characters than the actual animation (which remains amazing).
Violence was also very apparent in this movie, and that left me shocked. Yes, it was a movie about super heroes but it’s also a Disney movie. People were left shocked after the “Lion King’s” single death, so I’m curious why mothers aren’t creating an uproar about the gun use and constant explosions.
All in all, this movie falls short from “Finding Nemo” for me. While I can quote “Nemo” on a drop of a dime, it takes me a little while longer to find a single, hilarious quote from “The Incredibles.” Sorry Pixar, maybe next time.

A superb display of comedy and CGI

Stephen Floyd

The Advocate

“The Incredibles” was nothing less and so much more.

It’s a story about a family of superheroes forced to hide their powers from the rest of the world. But Bob “Mr. Incredible” Parr longs for the glory days where he could use his super strength for the good of mankind instead of work for an uptight insurance agency. His wife “Elastigirl” sympathizes with him, but reminds him that he now has a family to care for and no time for heroics.

When Bob is contacted for a secret mission that requires the full use of his skills, he can’t resist one more chance to relive his old life and become Mr. Incredible again. But he soon learns he has been duped by the evil genius Syndrome who has a chip on his shoulder that even Mr. Incredible would have trouble lifting.
As moviegoers have come to expect from a Pixar movie, “The Incredibles” is wet-your-pants funny. It might not have the constant comic momentum of other Pixar movies, but the parts that are funny really hit their mark. No one will forget the comic rants of Edna Mode, supersuit designer extraordinaire. This short, eccentric character is eager to outdo herself and to show off her superb supersuit making abilities. But for all intents and purposes, she can be a little pushy and not the least bit presumptuous, which only adds to her flair.

Besides a cool plot and lots of comic relief, “The Incredibles” offers fans a view into the advances made in computer generated graphics (CGI). I remember being disgusted with how people moved and looked in “Toy Story,” but it is safe to say that Pixar has made leaps and bounds with skins and biological motion since then. As Syndrome would say, “I’m still geeking out over it!” The characters look like an actual being is moving instead of a marionette, and the colors have texture instead of just being all shiny. If people knew how many lines of code and algorithms go into making it look like a real person is in the movie, they would be bored to tears. We haven’t seen many people in a Pixar film because those attributes had not been perfected, but it is clear that “The Incredibles” serves as a showcase for CGI advances.

“The Incredibles” is a great movie I can’t wait to take my sister to see. Ever since “Finding Nemo” came out, the students at her college in Georgia have quoted practically every line from the movie. But it’s only a matter of time until a passing stranger comes up to her and says, “Woman, where’s my super suit?”